Guild Applications

Gabriel Rodriguez

Status: REJECTED
Submitted on: Feb 16, 2010 at 01:26 AM

Damage Control Guild Application

Your Name

Gabriel Rodriguez

Main Character

VÄnity

Race and Class
Blood Elf Priest
Your Age:

22

What time zone do you live in?

Central

Have you ever applied to Damage Control before?

No

Please provide more detailed information about yourself below

Previous guilds & why you left -- please include transfer information:

Plenilune Discordia - Current Guild. My brother and I made this guild for personal reason, which are mostly materials and what not.
Audacity - Reason why I left was due to loot problems in which the Guild Master would give himself about anything he needed, even if the certain item was merely a sidegrade to him.
Brakebein - Reason I left Brakebein was mostly to do with the guild's decision to transfer to a "larger" group who raided 25 man content.

Raid Experience:

I recently came back to playing WoW due to my recent move from Pennsylvania and had no access to a reliable computer. I've raided and completed most WoTLK content, but most recently started raiding ICC 10 and have gone as far as Lord Saurfang. Never having been part of a "well" organized guild led me to have never really attempt hardmodes in Ulduar or ToGC, but I'm a quick learner and am aware of my surroudings whenever I'm raiding.

Why are you applying to Damage Control?

The reason I'm applying to Damage Control is that I'm really attracted to how well organized this guild seems to be having read the "About Us" section. You, as a guild, really seem to know what you're doing and seem to expect a lot from your raiders, which is what I'm looking for.

Please tell us how you are currently working to "gear up" your toon and maximize your raid output (such as running heroics, PuGs, crafting, PvP, arena, etc.) and what current stats you're looking to improve.

Currently, I'm working on crafting the new ICC pattern for "feet" by doing the daily frost random and getting into ICC10 pugs. Also, I'm grinding heroics and doing BGs to update my PvP gear since I haven't really had a time to do so.

Are you prepared to rotate your raid spot?

I'd be ready to do what is necessary even if it means letting someone else take my spot incase they've got one to many healers or someone else might've deserved it more than I have. I'm looking to gear up, but I know that doesn't mean I'll be geared with the first, or even the fourth, raid I attend.

Do you have Ventrilo and a working mic?

I do have Ventrillo, but no mic at the moment since my son accidenlty chewed the receiver.

References (if applicable):

Additional information you'd like us to consider:

There isn't really much I'd have to say, other then that I hope you give me chance as I'm a well-rounded player, skill and experienced. Thank you for having taken the time to read and evaluate my application.

11 Comments
Diendovalis
Anyone run anything with this guy yet?
Ranged
I'll doo something once I figure out how to add his name.... stupid symbols
Cranberry
^
Slridah
I should reject this person for just having stupid characters in their name. Unless somebody is having consistent feedback and follow up with this person I'm going to close app.
Xentin
He didn't even start a feedback thread in the Application Feedback section of the forum. Can't follow directions? Check! Doesn't actively try to run groups with memebers? Check!. Reject appliaction? Check!
Diendovalis
On a side note; I just get new phone service with At&t and when I call people it shows up on their caller ID as Gabrielle Rodriguez.
Jbean
Hey guys. Let's not be hasty.... Communication issues aside, this app is fairly well filled out. His gear looks reasonable given his experience, and he answered the "what are you doing to gear up" question well. Especially with Pascal in a questionable raiding place at the moment, I think it would be wrong to not at least give him a shot.
Diendovalis
Anyone run anything with this guy yet?
Xentin
No I agree with you bean. And I appreciate the guy coming back without an attitude, filling out the application section, then being a good sport about it. I understand mistakes can be made.

I'm not an expert, but his gear looks good, he seems experienced, and is in our age range. Plus what you say about Icy is true.

Since people are having trouble adding him or finding him in-game, maybe note how you type your name into the friend's list, and also add some of us and whisper us to run heroics.
Diendovalis
I found him in under the guild tag Crimson Wings. He didn't mention this guild on his app (maybe recently joined within the last day or two) I ran some heroics and a VoA with him. He did very well in both scenarios. I would recommend at least a 10 man trial in the near future.
Xentin
So I figured I'd comment on healing effectiveness from the last couple of nights he ran with us. I am not an expert by any means on Holy Priests, but I do know how to analyze WoL data really, really well.

As a holy priest, on fights like BQL where there is a butt load of raid damage going out, this should be your bread and butter fight. You should be destroying most every other healer, except likely a resto druid.

After analyzing several of the logs from last night and comparing it to other Holy Priests in different guilds who have attempted/defeated the encounter, I noticed a few things you could work on:

1) When there is constant raid damage, especially implemented through a raid wide aura, you should be spamming COH on cooldown. You used COH 171 times during a 5m 31s attempt. A log from a priest in Unreasonable who defeated the encounter 30 seconds faster than us, cast COH 252 times.

2) Additionally, your usage of Renew seems low. My understanding is this should be a spell you use liberally in large raid damage fights. Your renew accounted for about 10% of your healing on most fights, while the same priest from above it accounted for about 20% of their healing. Gear could be a factor here however.

3) I'm not sure what your mana levels were like over the course of the fight, but I noticed according to the logs, several times you didn't use your Shadowfiend (I know there were several fights were you did also). You can comment on this, but if you weren't having mana problems you were not healing hard enough. I'm not talking about blindly healing full health targets, but just pushing yourself to take more risks and not be so conservative with mana.

When I end a fight, especially in ICC25, if I have more than 10% mana, I feel like I didn't heal as well as I should have.

4) I big thing about healing is maintaining your raid environment awareness. Maybe someone else can comment on this, as I didn't specifically pay attention to this last night.

------------------------------------

Again, just a few things I noticed, based purely on logs, and not knowing that much about the priest class. So I could be wrong on much of it, but was just sparking some conversation since no one else had commented on performance. I'm not sure how much is gear related vs. skill + reaction time.

Granted the priest I was comparing you against is in Unreasonable and is in mostly BIS gear, I think skill often precedes gear when it comes to healing so I think some of the comparisons are apt.

Log for Celeese
http://www.worldoflogs.com/reports/yvlysjlc7wgojv67/details/11/?s=3819&e=4129